BHT (butylated hydroxytoluene)

Butylated Hydroxytoluene (BHT) is a synthetic antioxidant widely used in the food industry to prevent the oxidation of fats and oils, which helps extend shelf life. It is highly lipid soluble.

🌿 What is BHT?

• Chemical formula: C₁₅H₂₄O. It is chemically called 3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxytoluene.
• Structure: BHT is a derivative of phenol, with tert-butyl groups attached to the aromatic ring, giving it a bulky, stable structure.
• Function: It prevents lipid peroxidation — the oxidative degradation of lipids — by donating hydrogen atoms to free radicals, stabilizing them and halting chain reactions.

---

🍞 Uses in Foods

BHT is used in a range of high-fat, shelf-stable products, often in combination with other antioxidants like BHA (butylated hydroxyanisole):

• Cheese: Added to processed cheese to slow the oxidation of fats, preventing rancidity.
• Meat products: Used in cured meats (like sausages) to stabilize fat content and maintain color.
• Baked goods: Incorporated into products with a high fat content (like pastries or biscuits) to prevent spoilage.
• Snacks: Common in potato chips, crackers, and other fried snacks to delay oxidation and keep them crisp.
• Packaging: Commonly added to food wrappings and packaging. Part of active packaging too.

BHT is often mixed with other stabilizers, as its effectiveness increases when combined with other antioxidants like ascorbic acid (vitamin C) or citric acid.

---

⚗️ How BHT Works — The Chemistry

• Free radical scavenging: BHT neutralizes free radicals by donating a hydrogen atom from its phenolic group:

  ROO•+BHT-OH→ROOH+BHT-O•

• The BHT radical (BHT-O•) is stable due to the electron-donating tert-butyl groups, preventing it from further propagating oxidative reactions.

• BHT can also chelate metal ions (like iron or copper), which often catalyze oxidation, adding to its protective effect.

---

📏 Measurement of BHT in Foods

BHT levels are strictly regulated and measured using methods like:

• Gas Chromatography (GC): Separates BHT from other compounds for precise quantification.
• High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC): Used to detect BHT in complex food matrices.
• Spectrophotometry: Measures BHT’s absorbance at specific wavelengths.

Permitted levels:

• The FDA (U.S.) limits BHT in foods to 0.02% by weight of the fat or oil content.
• The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) sets a daily intake limit of 0.25 mg per kg of body weight.

Choice of Solvents

The choice of solvent depends on the food matrix — especially the fat content — to ensure maximum extraction efficiency. Let’s go food group by food group:

---

🧀 1. High-Fat Foods (Cheese, Meats, Oils, Butter)

Solvents:

• Hexane (non-polar): Dissolves fats and BHT effectively.
• Ethanol/Acetonitrile: Used to precipitate proteins after fat extraction.
• Methanol: Sometimes combined with hexane to boost BHT solubility.

Method:

1. Extract fat with hexane.
2. Precipitate proteins by adding ethanol or acetonitrile.
3. Centrifuge and collect the supernatant containing BHT.

Why? Hexane isolates BHT from the lipid phase, while ethanol or acetonitrile clears proteins.

---

🍞 2. Baked Goods (Biscuits, Cakes, Pastries)

Solvents:

• Methanol: Good for dissolving BHT and breaking down starches.
• Acetone: Helps remove interfering pigments and sugars.
• Ethanol:Water (80:20): Used to enhance recovery by making BHT more soluble in the polar environment.

Method:

1. Homogenize the baked sample.
2. Add methanol and acetone mixture.
3. Filter and collect the liquid phase for analysis.

Why? Methanol dissolves BHT even when fats are low, and acetone helps clean up matrix interferences.

---

🥓 3. Processed Meats (Sausages, Bacon, etc.)

Solvents:

• Isopropanol:Hexane (50:50): Extracts BHT from both fat and lean portions.
• Acetonitrile: Helps remove polar contaminants like salts and spices.

Method:

1. Mix sample with isopropanol:hexane.
2. Centrifuge to separate the fat layer.
3. Collect the organic layer containing BHT.

Why? The dual solvent blend balances polar and non-polar components, essential for complex meat matrices.

---

🥔 4. Snack Foods (Potato Chips, Crackers, Popcorn)

Solvents:

• Hexane: Dissolves fat and BHT.
• Acetonitrile: Removes starch and flavor compounds.
• Methanol: Sometimes used to improve BHT solubility.

Method:

1. Grind the snack food.
2. Add hexane and acetonitrile.
3. Filter the mixture and collect the hexane phase.

Why? The combination efficiently separates BHT from both fat and carbohydrate components.

---

🥛 5. Beverages (Fortified Drinks, Dairy Drinks)

Solvents:

• Ethanol:Water (70:30): Extracts BHT from aqueous solutions.
• Chloroform: Used for phase separation when fats are minimal.

Method:

1. Mix drink with ethanol:water.
2. Add chloroform for phase separation.
3. Collect organic layer for BHT detection.

Why? Since beverages are mostly water, ethanol helps dissolve BHT while chloroform pulls it into an organic layer for analysis.

---

🍬 6. Candies and Sweets (High-Sugar Matrices)

Solvents:

• Acetone:Water (80:20): Dissolves BHT while breaking down sugar.
• Ethanol: Helps keep BHT soluble in sugary matrices.

Method:

1. Dissolve candy in acetone:water.
2. Filter out undissolved sugar and collect the clear solution for testing.

Why? Sugars complicate extractions, so acetone reduces their solubility while keeping BHT in solution.

---

✅ Quick Summary of Solvent Choices

Food Type	Solvent(s)	Why It Works
High-fat foods	Hexane + Ethanol/Acetonitrile	Dissolves fat and separates proteins
Baked goods	Methanol + Acetone	Breaks down starch + dissolves BHT
Processed meats	Isopropanol + Hexane	Extracts from fat and lean meat
Snack foods	Hexane + Acetonitrile	Isolates BHT from carbs and fats
Beverages	Ethanol + Chloroform	Separates water and fat phases
Sweets/Candies	Acetone + Water	Solubilizes BHT, reduces sugar

Packaging

Antioxidants generally can be added to packaging either incorporated into the waxy layers of wraps for meats and cheeses say but also incorporated into the papers that make up that packaging. Butylated hydroxytoluene has been coextruded into low density polyethylene (LDPE) at different levels up to 14 mg/g.

Precise Analytical Methods

1. Gas Chromatography (GC)

Method:

• Sample preparation usually involves solid-phase extraction (SPE) or liquid-liquid extraction (LLE) to isolate BHT from the food matrix.
• The extract is injected into the gas chromatograph equipped with a flame ionization detector (FID) or a mass spectrometer (MS).
• BHT elutes at a specific retention time, and its concentration is calculated by comparing the sample’s peak area to a calibration curve made from known BHT standards.

Why use GC?

• High sensitivity (detection limits as low as 0.01 mg/kg).
• Suitable for complex fatty matrices (like oils, snacks, or processed meats).

---

2. High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)

Method:

• Samples are extracted using solvents like methanol or acetonitrile.
• The extract is injected into an HPLC system with a UV detector (usually set at 280 nm to match BHT’s absorption peak).
• A C18 reverse-phase column is often used for separation.
• Quantification is done by comparing the peak area to that of known BHT standards.

Why use HPLC?

• Excellent for non-volatile samples or food products with minimal fat.
• Detection limits can be as low as 0.02 mg/kg.

---

3. Spectrophotometry (UV-Vis)

Method:

• BHT absorbs UV light at around 280 nm.
• After extraction with ethanol or methanol, absorbance is measured directly using a UV-Vis spectrophotometer.
• The BHT concentration is calculated using Beer-Lambert’s law:

A=ε⋅c⋅l

where:

• $A$ = absorbance
• $\epsilon$ = molar absorption coefficient
• $c$ = concentration
• $l$ = path length

Why use UV-Vis?

• Simple and cost-effective.
• Less sensitive than GC or HPLC — often used for routine screening rather than trace-level detection.

---

4. Thin-Layer Chromatography (TLC)

Method:

• BHT is extracted using organic solvents.
• The extract is spotted onto a silica gel plate.
• The plate is developed in a solvent system (e.g., hexane:acetone mixture), separating BHT from other components.
• Visualization is done using UV light or a color-developing spray (like 2,6-dichloroquinone-chlorimide solution).

Why use TLC?

• Quick, low-cost method for qualitative analysis or screening for BHT.
• Less precise for exact quantification compared to GC or HPLC.

---

5. Combined GC-MS (Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry)

Method:

• Same sample preparation as GC.
• The mass spectrometer detects BHT based on its molecular ion peak (m/z = 220).
• This method provides both quantitative data (BHT concentration) and qualitative confirmation (identity of the compound).

Why use GC-MS?

• Extremely sensitive (detection limits can be as low as 0.001 mg/kg).
• Ideal for verifying BHT presence in highly complex matrices like processed meats or bakery items.

---

Summary of Detection Limits and Suitability:

Method	Detection Limit	Best for
GC-FID	0.01 mg/kg	Fats, oils, meat products
HPLC-UV	0.02 mg/kg	Non-volatile foods (baked goods)
UV-Vis	0.1 mg/kg	Quick screening
TLC	1 mg/kg (qualitative)	Preliminary checks
GC-MS	0.001 mg/kg	High-sensitivity testing

---

👅 Taste and Aftertaste

• At low levels: BHT is generally tasteless and odorless.
• At high concentrations: It can impart a slightly chemical, medicinal, or bitter aftertaste.
• Foods high in fat (like fried snacks) are more prone to this aftertaste, as BHT interacts directly with lipid components.

Taste Profile of BHT in Cheese

1. Low concentrations (under 0.02 mg/kg):

   • Virtually no perceptible taste or aroma.
   • Helps prevent rancidity by slowing the oxidation of fats, indirectly preserving the cheese’s natural flavour.

2. Moderate levels (around 0.02–0.1 mg/kg):

   • Slightly waxy or medicinal notes may start to emerge.
   • Some describe a faint plastic-like or rubbery aftertaste, especially in aged or high-fat cheeses (like cheddar or gouda).

3. High concentrations (above 0.1 mg/kg):

   • Noticeable chemical, bitter, or soapy flavours.
   • Can clash with the natural tanginess of cheeses, giving a synthetic, astringent finish.
   • These off-flavours are more obvious in soft, high-moisture cheeses, as the BHT can more readily dissolve and distribute through the fat content.

---

🧀 Why does BHT affect taste in cheese?

• Fat solubility: BHT is lipophilic, meaning it dissolves in fat. In fatty cheeses, it can integrate into the lipid phase and influence flavour more directly.
• Oxidation reactions: Although BHT prevents fat oxidation, at higher levels, it can itself degrade slightly over time, forming compounds like tert-butylquinone that contribute to unpleasant tastes.
• Synergistic effects: When combined with other antioxidants (like BHA or TBHQ), the off-flavours may be more pronounced, adding to the bitterness or medicinal notes.

 

---

🔬 Regulations and taste thresholds:

• The EU limit in cheese is typically not more than 0.02% (200 mg/kg) in fat content — though most manufacturers use far less to avoid affecting taste.
• Sensory studies suggest the taste threshold for BHT ranges between 0.1–0.5 mg/kg in high-fat foods before off-flavours become noticeable.

Taste Profile of BHT in Baked Goods

1. Low concentrations (under 0.02 mg/kg):

   • No detectable taste or smell.
   • Helps maintain the fresh, buttery, or sweet aroma by preventing fat oxidation.
   • Typically used in products with longer shelf lives, like biscuits, cakes, and pastries.

2. Moderate levels (0.02–0.1 mg/kg):

   • Slightly medicinal or plastic-like aftertaste may appear.
   • Some describe a faint waxy or chemical flavour, especially in butter-heavy or oil-rich baked goods like shortbread or croissants.
   • The aftertaste can linger, giving a subtle bitterness or “synthetic” feel, which might clash with delicate flavours like vanilla or citrus.

3. High concentrations (above 0.1 mg/kg):

   • Noticeable bitter, soapy, or astringent notes.
   • Can suppress the sweetness of cakes or cookies.
   • In pastries or high-fat doughs, BHT may add a rubbery or petroleum-like flavour — especially when the product is stored for long periods.
   • These off-flavours are more obvious in low-moisture items like crackers or dry biscuits, where the antioxidant has less liquid to dilute its presence.

---

🥐 Why does BHT impact taste in baked goods?

• Fat solubility: BHT dissolves in oils and fats, so high-fat recipes (butter cookies, brioche) are more prone to picking up these off-notes.
• Heat stability: BHT is heat-stable, but if baked goods are overcooked, degradation compounds like tert-butylquinone can form, adding bitterness.
• Ingredient interactions: In some cases, BHT may interact with flavour compounds (like vanilla, cocoa, or fruit extracts), muting their aromas or causing strange aftertastes.

---

✅ Regulatory levels and sensory thresholds

• The FDA permits BHT at levels up to 0.02% (200 mg/kg) of the fat content in baked goods.
• Sensory studies show that BHT off-flavours become noticeable starting at 0.1–0.5 mg/kg — especially in low-moisture products like crackers.

---

⚖️ Considerations and Controversy

Though BHT is considered safe within approved limits, there’s ongoing debate about its long-term health impacts. Some studies have suggested it may have:

• Pro-oxidant effects at very high levels.
• Potential links to hormonal disruption or carcinogenicity in animal models — though evidence is inconclusive for humans.