Protein secretion in Escherichia coli is a fundamental cellular process that enables proteins to reach their correct cellular or extracellular destinations. As a Gram-negative bacterium, E. coli possesses a complex cell envelope consisting of an inner (cytoplasmic) membrane, a periplasmic space containing the peptidoglycan layer, and an outer membrane. Proteins synthesized in the cytoplasm must therefore be selectively and accurately transported across one or both membranes. Among the several protein export and secretion systems present in E. coli, the Sec (general secretory) pathway and the twin-arginine translocation (Tat) pathway are the two primary mechanisms responsible for translocating proteins across the inner membrane. These pathways differ in their substrates, mechanisms, energetic requirements, and biological roles, yet together they account for the majority of inner-membrane protein export in the organism.
Overview of Protein Secretion in E. coli
Protein secretion in E. coli can be broadly divided into two stages: translocation across the inner membrane and subsequent targeting to the periplasm, outer membrane, or extracellular environment. The Sec and Tat pathways mediate the first of these stages. Proteins exported by these pathways may remain soluble in the periplasm, be inserted into the inner membrane, or be further transported across the outer membrane via additional secretion systems (e.g., Type II secretion) or outer-membrane assembly machineries (such as the Bam complex for β-barrel proteins).
Both the Sec and Tat systems rely on N-terminal signal peptides that direct proteins to the appropriate translocation machinery. However, the nature of these signal peptides, the folding state of the substrate proteins, and the molecular mechanisms of transport differ substantially between the two pathways.
The Sec Pathway
General Features
The Sec pathway is the primary and most ubiquitous protein export route in E. coli and in bacteria more broadly (Pugsley, 1990). It is often referred to as the “general secretory pathway” because it transports the majority of secreted and periplasmic proteins, as well as many inner-membrane proteins. A defining feature of the Sec pathway is that it translocates proteins in an unfolded or loosely folded state.
Sec substrates typically contain an N-terminal signal peptide composed of three regions: (1) a positively charged N-region, (2) a central hydrophobic H-region, and (3) a polar C-region containing a signal peptidase cleavage site. This signal peptide is recognized by the Sec machinery and is usually removed following translocation.
Core Components
The central element of the Sec pathway is the SecYEG translocon, a heterotrimeric protein complex embedded in the inner membrane. SecY forms the main translocation channel, while SecE and SecG stabilize the structure and contribute to its function. The channel is gated to prevent ion leakage and opens transiently during protein translocation.
The ATPase SecA provides the driving force for post-translational translocation of many Sec substrates. SecA binds both the preprotein and the SecYEG complex and undergoes cycles of ATP binding and hydrolysis that push segments of the unfolded polypeptide through the translocon. In addition to ATP hydrolysis, the proton motive force across the inner membrane also contributes to translocation efficiency.
Co-translational and Post-translational Modes
The Sec pathway operates in two distinct modes: co-translational and post-translational translocation. In co-translational translocation, membrane proteins are targeted to the SecYEG complex while they are still being synthesized by the ribosome. This process is mediated by the signal recognition particle (SRP), which recognizes hydrophobic signal sequences or transmembrane helices emerging from the ribosome. The ribosome–nascent chain complex is then delivered to the Sec translocon, allowing insertion of transmembrane segments directly into the lipid bilayer.
In post-translational translocation, typically used for periplasmic and secreted proteins, the completed polypeptide is maintained in an unfolded state in the cytoplasm by chaperones such as SecB. SecB prevents premature folding and delivers the substrate to SecA, which then drives translocation through SecYEG.
Signal Peptide Cleavage and Folding
Once the protein has crossed the inner membrane, the signal peptide is cleaved by signal peptidase. The mature protein is released into the periplasm, where it folds into its native conformation, often with the assistance of periplasmic chaperones and folding catalysts such as Dsb proteins (for disulfide bond formation) and peptidyl-prolyl isomerases.
The Tat Pathway
General Features
The twin-arginine translocation (Tat) pathway represents a mechanistically distinct system for protein export across the inner membrane. Unlike the Sec pathway, the Tat system transports proteins that are fully folded in the cytoplasm, often containing complex cofactors such as metal clusters or prosthetic groups. This capability allows E. coli to export proteins whose folding or cofactor insertion is incompatible with post-translocation maturation.
Tat substrates are characterized by a conserved signal peptide containing a twin-arginine motif, typically denoted as S/TRRxFLK, in the N-region of the signal peptide. This motif is essential for recognition by the Tat machinery and distinguishes Tat substrates from those of the Sec pathway.
Core Components
In E. coli, the Tat pathway consists of three essential membrane proteins: TatA, TatB, and TatC. TatC and TatB form a receptor complex that recognizes the twin-arginine signal peptide of substrate proteins. TatA, which is present in multiple copies, is thought to assemble into oligomeric structures that form the translocation pore or otherwise destabilize the membrane to allow passage of folded proteins.
Unlike the Sec translocon, the Tat system does not form a permanent protein-conducting channel of fixed diameter. Instead, it is highly dynamic, assembling transiently in response to substrate binding.
Energetics and Mechanism
A key distinguishing feature of the Tat pathway is its energy source. Tat-dependent translocation is driven exclusively by the proton motive force across the inner membrane and does not require ATP hydrolysis. This reliance on the electrochemical gradient underscores the fundamentally different mechanism of transport compared to the Sec system.
The precise molecular mechanism of Tat transport remains an area of active investigation. Current models suggest that substrate binding to the TatBC complex triggers recruitment and oligomerization of TatA, leading to localized membrane thinning or transient pore formation that accommodates the folded substrate. Following translocation, the TatA complex disassembles.
Substrate Maturation and Function
Because Tat substrates are translocated in a folded state, they typically undergo complete folding and cofactor incorporation in the cytoplasm prior to export. This is particularly important for enzymes involved in anaerobic respiration and redox reactions, such as nitrate reductases and hydrogenases, many of which are Tat-dependent. After translocation and signal peptide cleavage, Tat substrates function in the periplasm or associate with the inner membrane.
Comparison of the Sec and Tat Pathways
Folding State of Substrates
The most fundamental difference between the Sec and Tat pathways is the folding state of the transported proteins. The Sec pathway requires substrates to be largely unfolded during translocation, whereas the Tat pathway uniquely accommodates fully folded proteins, including those with tightly bound cofactors. This distinction has significant implications for protein biogenesis and cellular organization.
Signal Peptides and Targeting
Both pathways rely on N-terminal signal peptides, but these peptides are distinct in sequence and recognition features. Sec signal peptides lack the twin-arginine motif and are defined primarily by their hydrophobic H-region. Tat signal peptides contain the highly conserved twin-arginine motif, which is critical for targeting to the Tat machinery and for preventing mistargeting to the Sec pathway.
Translocation Machinery and Energetics
The Sec pathway employs a stable protein-conducting channel (SecYEG) and uses both ATP hydrolysis (via SecA) and the proton motive force. In contrast, the Tat pathway uses a dynamic, substrate-induced assembly of TatA oligomers and relies solely on the proton motive force. The absence of ATP consumption in Tat transport reflects its lower throughput and more specialized role.
Substrate Range and Throughput
The Sec pathway handles a wide range of substrates and accounts for the majority of protein export events in E. coli. It is highly efficient and capable of continuous operation, particularly in co-translational mode. The Tat pathway, by comparison, exports a smaller and more specialized set of proteins, often involved in redox processes or stress responses, and operates at a lower overall capacity.
Biological Roles and Evolutionary Considerations
From a physiological perspective, the Sec pathway is indispensable for cell viability, as it supports the biogenesis of essential membrane and periplasmic proteins. The Tat pathway, while not universally essential under laboratory conditions, provides critical advantages in specific environmental contexts, such as anaerobic growth or utilization of alternative electron acceptors.
Evolutionarily, the Sec pathway is highly conserved across all domains of life, including eukaryotes, where it underpins protein targeting to the endoplasmic reticulum. The Tat pathway is more restricted in distribution but is found in many bacteria, archaea, and plant chloroplasts, highlighting its specialized yet important role in cellular physiology.
Protein secretion in E. coli is a highly organized and tightly regulated process that ensures proteins reach their correct cellular destinations. The Sec and Tat pathways represent two fundamentally different solutions to the challenge of transporting proteins across the hydrophobic inner membrane. The Sec pathway, with its requirement for unfolded substrates and its reliance on ATP and the proton motive force, serves as the primary and most versatile export route. The Tat pathway, by contrast, provides a unique mechanism for the translocation of fully folded, often cofactor-containing proteins using only the proton motive force.
Together, these pathways allow E. coli to balance efficiency, versatility, and functional specialization in protein secretion. Understanding their mechanisms and interplay not only provides insight into bacterial cell biology but also has practical implications for biotechnology, where these systems are frequently exploited for heterologous protein production and secretion.
References
Pugsley, A. P. (1990). Translocation of proteins with signal sequences across membranes. Current Opinion in Cell Biology, 2(4), pp. 609-616
Leave a Reply